| Valur W |
| Return from loan |
| - | Valur W | Afturelding W | Loan |
| 02 may 2025 | Keflavik W | Valur W | Free agent |
| - | IR Reykjavik W | Keflavik W | Return from loan |
| - | Keflavik W | IR Reykjavik W | Loan |
| - | Grindavik W | Keflavik W | Free agent |
| 02 feb 2023 | Keflavik W | Grindavik W | Free agent |
E. Gustavsdottir career history shows progression across clubs and competitions, including club timeline, national team appearances and overall career totals.